On a recent Sunday morning I was getting ready for church, in fact I was in the shower where all good thinking seems to begin, and I began to wonder what was in store for us that morning. The more I thought, the more questions I had. The questions weren’t really spontaneous but more like a culmination of sorts, an amalgam of thinking from the preceding months, and even years. The heart of the question was why do our church services (in a variety of congregations and denominations that I visit) look the way they look? More specifically, why do most services revolve around someone instructing us for about 30 minutes, or more? Why is the sermon the focal point of the entire service? Is this really focusing on Jesus? Is this what Jesus intended when He instituted the church?
I speak with a lot of pastors about strategy, service design, structure, vision, mission and a host of other topics, but this specific line of thought and questioning is fresh for me. Preaching has always been an accepted part of the weekly gathering, at least in modern history. Most folks, including myself consider it sacred and would never consider lowering its place of prominence in a service. But this particular morning my thoughts were going elsewhere, and I’ve not been able to sideline either my thoughts or my questions since they began. In fact, I’ve leaned into them and explored them on a deeper level.
Somehow we’ve gotten to the place where we’ve divided the “service of worship” into two segments: Worship, and Bible Teaching. So much so that we often hear the comments, “Great worship today,” or “Great teaching today.” I just can’t accept that as being appropriate any longer. Here’s where I am: Because we’ve decided the weekly gathering is primarily an attractional event for evangelizing the lost or instructing believers our focus is not on celebrating Christ and His kingdom on the earth.
What would a service look like if the focus were not the sermon or a particular style of music? What if we really gathered to celebrate the kingdom of Christ? What would we stop doing? What would we start doing? Perhaps you’re part of a church already focused on the kingdom of Christ. Perhaps you’re developing a hunger for such a gathering, or perhaps you think I’m a bit foolish for even thinking about this. I wonder if our services aren’t kingdom of Christ focused because we don’t think that’s an attainable goal, or it doesn’t look like what we’ve come to expect from the modern church? I wonder if it’s because we’ve turned the church into our hired hands for evangelism and without a seeker event we feel we have no other means of exposing the lost to Jesus.
As you can tell, I’m doing a lot of wondering these days. I’m not suggesting we abandon music or the Bible but I am wondering what it would look like to be more like the early Christians in Acts. Not really sure where this is taking me, and not sure what this even has to do with my current role in life but the journey continues.
August 12, 2008 at 12:30 am
Mark, I love that you’re engaged with these questions.
In some ways what you’re describing feels a little more like what I would call from my experience, “liturgical worship”…I don’t actually mean in the standard sense, except to say that everything within it…from the sacrament of scripture to the singing of song serve as worship of God.
Along that vein it is apparent that not all Church has put “bible teaching” front and center. I’ve been impressed that several episcopal or celtic christian churches I’ve visited here in Portland the focus is decidedly NOT on exposition but rather the pure and transforming affect of the uninterpreted Word of God…very different from my standard evangelical experience.
Finally I would comment on two thoughts I’d like to hold in tension. The first is out of Isaiah 58, and other prophetic voices, such as Amos and Micah, and is continued through the prophetic ministry of Jesus and then in the church through James: true worship. “I’m tired of your sacred assemblies…you seek me daily…you delight to know my ways (as if you did justice)…yet is this the kind of fast [and I would insert "worship"] I have required?…do justice, love mercy, walk humbly with God.”
This is the nature of true faith and real worship. Does God care for our effusive worship songs and praise choruses? Is He in need of our constant “Jesus My Boyfriend” romancing the Divine? Or is it as Father Richard Rohr suggests, a subtle way for the human psyche to satisfy its sensibilities? In other words…if I focus on the messenger…if I lift him up and preach jesus…I can forget what He said…I can disregard the message altogether. Is our labor and are our energies misappropriated according to God’s own heart?
At the same time I remember John Wesley describing “kingdom colonies”, where mutual accountability and exhortation for the living out of the good news occurs. Those seem to me to be infinitly valuable. A society of transformation in which every element is dedicated to the furthering of God’s good dream…
Anyhow…sorry I took up so much space on your post…really good thoughts and questions though. They got me going.
Cheers
August 12, 2008 at 1:20 am
That’s a good thought.
Like Brittian said in his comment, God makes it clear what he wants out of our “worship services”; “and what does the Lord require of you? To act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with the Lord your God”. And yet at the same time, the community aspect of what John Wesley described cannot be forgotten about. It seems to be so crucial.
But…are we really doing any of this? And if we are, are we doing it in the best way possible?
It forces me to rethink what the context of a sunday morning “needs” to be, and within that context where does all of this fit or not fit.
In other words, and this might give some pastors and worship leaders a heart attack;
do we need music?
or do we need a sermon?
Most people might quickly size up my age, and say I’m a rebel spirited post-modern hipped (whatever that means), and say that that I’m just trying to get rid of church, or to change everything.
On the contrary, I tend to think that everything has already changed, and it’s about time we figure out exactly what we are doing on sunday mornings. Because sometimes, it sure feels like we get up early, and enjoy wasting a few hours.
I wonder, and I think this is pointing back to a blog post you had a while ago…
What’s the big idea?
September 26, 2008 at 11:10 pm
i am moseying around reading different articles/blogs tonight and i clicked your link from sensualjesus’ link and i am goign to chare the same link i did with him.
http://www.lincolnberean.org/equipping/sermons
one church (the date is 9-14-08)is the where the series begins. But i believe the Church is designed for worship…but…the Church is not fully developed yet…not till every tongue tribe and nation declares our Lords name will it be…and this is why we still have sermons…soo we grow and learn and we can equip others….but then there is the question what exactly is worship!?! isn’t worhip glorifying God?! can’t we Worship God sitting in the pew? or doing our duties at work? worship is more than singing. who knows why our services look the way they do and in the pattern they do. it is just they way it happens! yeah catered to our culture…a lot of times…but not all the time…
to response to phil.. i think that church is not just a building we waste a few hours in, in the morning…it is a community…juast as God gave adam eve…he gave us eachother…we need eachother we need community…i honestly believe the community is what keeps most of us going back to church….it is not a place that is perfect but it is a place filled with imperfect humans who need each other and are learning how to love each other together!
April 6, 2009 at 4:25 pm
Voli Dublino thinks you are right!